Like a Book I Wouldn’t Read

“I wish that confidence was all you could see in my eyes / Like those interviews in locker rooms with talented sports guys / I wish I had no self-awareness like the guys I know / Float right through their lives without a thought / And that I didn’t give a shit what anybody thought of me / That I was so relaxed you’d think that I was bored” – John Grant, “Silver Platter Club”

confidenceTwo weekends ago, at a recovery-related event, I was sitting outside smoking a cigarette and talking to a recently made friend.

The conversation turned to the topic of social anxiety, and I offered that I suffered from that particular affliction to an inordinate extent.

“Really?” my friend said. “I’d have never known, you seem so confident.”

I was taken aback for a moment, though pleased that I had managed to fool him, somehow.

I’ve been revisiting that conversation in my mind off and on since. If this man saw me as confident, did others?

The truth is, I’ve never had much confidence. Ego, hell yes. Confidence? never. At the far end of my 48th year, I still judge myself more harshly than anyone else ever could, and with astonishing frequency.

I’m not saying that there aren’t moments when I feel good about myself: I am proud of myself when I help other people, I can commend myself when I write something I believe to be worthwhile, and I even like the way I look on those rare days when skin, clothing, hair and body all coalesce to present an appearance I think looks pretty good. Those moments are sadly, few and far between, and they can be erased immediately by one misjudged look from another, a terrible photo of myself popping up on Facebook, or even the tiniest inadvertent criticism.

I’m also not saying that I am shy or retiring: Over the years, I’ve learned how to present the image of an alternate Andy, the Andy that I wish I could be organically. In my previous incarnation as a producer/production manager, it would have been career suicide to let my insecurities show. So I cultivated a brash, get-the-fucking-job-done personality that allowed me to progress without hindrance, job-wise,  until I was body-checked by my addiction in 2002. But it was mostly acting. I was as insecure about my performance…my legitimacy as a boss….as I may have often made the people who worked for me feel.

Now, having been humbled by my precipitous fall from grace, I can rarely muster that other Andy, the Andy of the False Bravado.  I sometimes feel like an actor who can no longer summon the motivations and mannerisms of a character he played a long time ago.  But it’s not necessarily a bad thing, because I no longer want false bravado, I want real courage.

I want to learn how to love myself, to stop judging myself, to stop being my own harshest critic.

I’ve been working hard this year towards that objective. At this point…eleven months clean and sober…the best I can say is that there are moments when I like myself. I still hate my face. I hate my big nose (“you have a Roman nose,” my father used to say. “It’s roamin’ all over your face.”), I hate my thick, short torso, I hate my  giant legs that look like I was bred to pull carts through fields. I hate the long scar on my belly that is a direct result of my drug use.


I want to go back in time and tell this kid to stop worrying about the paint job and start focusing on the engine..advice i’m trying to follow now.

I’m terrified of aging: in my youth, I was told I was handsome. I didn’t believe it, but empirically I knew it had to be true on some level. Looking back at photos of myself in my twenties, I see a beautiful boy. I wish I could have thought that about myself then.  There’s a big difference between knowing something to be true and feeling that it’s true. So for years, I relied on that perception of others to validate myself. Now, nearing fifty, my skin sagging and it’s tone uneven with age, my crow’s-feet wrapping so far around my head and so deep into my skin that they look like knife wounds if I smile too broadly, I have had to forfeit even the luxury…or curse, perhaps…of false confidence.

So, it’s just me left. Without the smooth shiny skin and clear white eyes of youth, without the superficial  validation of others, I’m unarmed for the most part. Yes, I’m intelligent, though perhaps not as much so as before I addled myself with crystal meth. Yes, I’m compassionate towards others. Yes, I’m regaining the capacity to be honest, another virtue torn to shreds by addiction. I have many good qualities, yet somehow there are times when those don’t seem to be enough.

While I do have a good number of close friends I’m completely comfortable with, my social anxiety is particularly bad in large groups of people: I stand talking to someone I’ve just met, and I’m conversationally crippled by my own thoughts, my own self-absorption. Can it be called narcissism, this thinking of myself when I should be focused on someone else, if the thoughts about myself are entirely negative?  I smile at people a lot, and they smile back. I hug people a lot, and they hug back. From there, however, it’s a difficult road to continue down.

In the gay recovery community, beautiful boys abound. Youth is everywhere, and I can’t help but compare myself to them, to envy the attention they get from others not because they are decent, respectable, admirable human beings (though many of them are, of course), but because they are shiny and lovely and golden.  I often feel left out, relegated to the past-their-prime seats, feeling less-than and, because i’m an addict and it’s what we’re good at, sorry for myself.

I shoot my face full of Botox, get injections of filler to stave off the inevitable collapse of the flesh-girders holding up my face, and I torture my body at the gym, all so I can feel better about my exterior, and perhaps fool one or two people into believing that I have some semblance of confidence, and perhaps, in the right lighting, look a few years younger than I actually am.

I’ve battled an eating disorder (if you read this blog you already know I’m a hundred flavors of fucked-up, so this should hardly be a surprise), I put myself through insanely  awful liposuction surgery (“There will be some pain during the recovery,” my plastic surgeon said, which turned out to be the equivalent of saying “Auschwitz lacks many of the comforts of home”), and I could competently give guided tours of every tanning booth in Southern California….all in a vain attempt to like myself.

I’m writing about this not for reassurance about my appearance. I understand I’m not hideous. I even understand that I am sometimes perceived as handsome. I understand that there are so many unfortunates with deformities and injuries and who are dealing with real problems. I get this. I do NOT want anyone to comment on this blog post to validate me for my physical exterior. I’m writing this because I still often feel ugly, on the inside, and I need to start letting that feeling  out.

I’m writing this because I want people to understand that if I seem stand-offish, it’s not because I don’t want to know you. If I say hello, then seem to drift away before conversation ensues, I want you to know it’s because there’s a fairly good chance I’m feeling incredibly awkward and want to get the fuck out of the situation before you realize it. I don’t want to say something stupid, so often I say nothing at all.

Mostly, however, I’m writing this because I know there are other people who feel this way…this weird social anxiety. Perhaps theirs isn’t based in the same insecurities mine are, but I know for a fact that I share these feelings of occasional self-loathing with many others. I’ve heard others who are far braver than I talk about it publicly in the places I go for recovery, and it usually surprises me because I’ve already assessed these people as being beautiful and confident.

This social anxiety, this non-stop judgement of self, is one of the reasons I loved alcohol and crystal meth so much.  When I was high, all this discomfort in my own skin disappeared. I was suddenly funny (or so I thought), and my self-criticism diminished to such a degree that I could actually relax around other people.  Now, clean and sober, I have to begin addressing these character defects in a direct way, and it’s terrifying.  But it has to be done if I’m ever going to find peace living here in this aging body of mine.

I need to escape this overwhelming self-absorption and find peace. I need to address what’s lacking inside so I can start caring less about what’s on the outside. I need to continue helping others so that I can stay out of my own head.

There are probably a good number of people reading this and thinking, “God, what a self-obsessed asshole.” Don’t feel bad, because I’m thinking that myself. But I need to get this out. This is the kind of shit that has been in my head for years and blocks my path to any kind of spiritual advancement. So, i’m getting it out, as obnoxious and narcissistic as it might sound. I do like to think that I might be helping other people with this blog, but the truth is that this blog helps me, and that’s the reason I blurch this confessional shit out onto the internet (and apparently, into NSA storage facilities..oh well.)

The long and short of this post is that I want to love myself with the same sincerity that I love others. When I look in the mirror, I want to see..and feel like…the man my amazing husband says I am: good, decent, worthwhile. I’m done with feeling like a book I would never want to read.

I think I deserve it. I hope I do, anyway.

(Fuck that: I  know I do.  It’s gonna take a lot of work, but I’m up for it. Just please bear with me and these blog entries until I get there.)

About andy nicastro

I'm a producer, writer, graphic designer, former overachiever, current procrastinator and occasional catastrophic fuckupper living in Los Angeles.

Posted on June 11, 2013, in 12 steps, addiction, alcoholism, drugs, recovery, spirituality and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 8 Comments.

  1. Andy, thank you for sharing your extraordinary gift of writing and describing what so many of us feel every minute of each day. Your unique and descriptive written voice brings back bittersweet memories from our meeting in the mid-nineties. We met in 1995 in Los Angeles when our dear friend Michael was terminally ill. At that time, I was in the early stages of the disease of alcoholism which took me another 10 years to find recovery, which led to another decade to put a stable recovery together. I am so very excited to have found your blog and experience your humor, honesty and strength. So delighted to hear you and Patrick are still going strong. My email is attached under separate cover – write me – love to catch up. Love, Sharon

    • OMG, Sharon!!! So great to hear from you!!!! And SOOOOOO happy you’re doing well, I had no idea you were dealing with that. Gonna go look for your email now. Have to run out right now, but will write later today or tomorrow. So happy you found me here! xxxxoooooo

  2. Andy, let me just start off by stating that you have always been a beautiful man, inside & out. As I sit here & cry as I write this to you, I can relate to this recent blog because I am struggling with self-image issues. As a child I was always told that I was not pretty, not thin enough, my hair was too curly, etc… It has affected me in so many ways. My alcohol use started when you & I were in Catholic school. My eating disorders, &drug use started in high school & followed me though my early 30’s. I too have known the pleasure of the Botox needle, torturing myself at the gym, putting myself through hundreds of facials, peels, etc. All to make myself look beautiful, because, after all, if you LOOK beautiful, you ARE beautiful. If you ARE beautiful then you FEEL beautiful on the inside. The vicious cycle. I had at one time, lost a lot of weight, and well, with my God given graces in the boob department, I slept with every guy that was gorgeous, hoping that would make me feel loved, but alas, treating them like a “guy” would treat a girl & just toss them away like used toilet paper the next day. I am still afraid of aging gracefully but trying to learn to accept who I am, flaws & all. For me it will always be a life-long struggle. XOXO

    • Thank you for sharing that, Kim…you’re an amazing woman and i’m so glad we’ve reconnected. Hang in there…i’ll do the same. Have a beautiful day. xxxoo back at you.

  3. andrea nicastro

    Andy, your honesty is as beautiful as you are. The way you describe your feelings is something I could never do; and not because I didnt have those same feelings; but because I dont have your talent with words. I think now, from the perspective of age that most of us feel that way to a certain degree either all or the time or sometimes. All along Andy, all through your battles of addiction the saving grace for you was always that you are a very very good person. You may disagree and your actions at times when you were using could be dangerous and hurtful. But you never once lost that very center part of you. The goodness, the ability to really love and the desire to help the people you love. You think I’m just saying this??? Go back to the blog you wrote describing that day in the hospital parking lot when you turned and ran BACK towards the men chasing you because you thought I needed you. I did need you baby doll but not because of a faked heart attack, I needed you because the thought of losing you was more than I could stand. So, when you look in the mirror and see something you dont like, look again, because if you do you will see the most gorgeous man, inside and out. A man who loves with the deepest love and will fiercely defend and help anyone who needs it, but particularly those you love. And I know I speak for your brother, your sister and your nieces and nephews when I say you are the best and you are loved so much.

  4. I feel the same way at times. I am not skilled at faking confidence though. Your beauty shines through in your writing however. Keep it up.

  5. First of all I want to comment on your external, physical beauty- you are frigging gorgeous. Your physical presence makes my day glow. Secondly, your blog helps me. If nothing else, every time you post, you enhance my moment. You are my big brother and my son.

    • you just made me cry. I love you so much and i’m so grateful for your guidance and love and wisdom and laughter. I thank God for you every single day for helping me the way you have. You are one of the first miracles of my sobriety and just seeing YOUR face fills me with joy. Thank you, Jonathan.

If you enjoyed this, please feel free to share. Or leave a comment here. Thanks!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: